The Dupe Report
10 Drugstore Dupes That Outperform Luxury Brands
We swatched, wore and re-bought these pharmacy finds beside their hundred-dollar counterparts. Six of them won.
By the Beauty Brochure editors
A good dupe is not a cheap copy; it is a formula that happens to cost less and perform. For six weeks our editors applied the same test to both sides of the aisle: same light, same skin, same half-face comparison.
The rule we set was simple. If we could not tell which side of the face had the expensive product at four in the afternoon, the dupe won. No brand was told we were testing, and nothing here was gifted.
The cheapest winner of the whole experiment is the mascara. Sixteen dollars, no clumps at any coat count, and a curl that survived a spin class. Our twenty-eight dollar favourite is now a very expensive second place.
The finishing oil is the other quiet triumph. Two drops on damp ends gave the same glassy seal as a bottle four times its price, and the scent was lighter. We keep one in the bathroom and one in the desk drawer.
Where luxury still wins: pigment payoff in the blush, and the packaging, which is half the pleasure. If you want a compact that feels like a small object of desire, budget accordingly. If you want a flush that photographs beautifully by noon, the dupe is enough.
Our advice for everyday shoppers is to spend on the formulas that stay on your skin all day — sunscreen, base, treatment — and save on the things you re-buy every eight weeks.
Beauty Brochure may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through the links in this issue, at no extra cost to you.